Skip to main content

Spooky Action at a Distance - The EPR Paradox


 Einstein’s paper with his two postdoctoral research companions, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen, was the great EPR paradox.”Can Quantum Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?” asks the paper.(1935). You might be surprised to learn that Einstein was the one who laid the groundwork for quantum mechanics in its early stages, only to propose that quantum physics is incomplete. Some refer to this as Einstein’s great mistake, which led to a tremendous quantum discovery. In this blog, I will discuss EPR briefly. However, it takes a fundamental understanding of quantum characteristics, which I am here to simplify.

Even now, this study is regarded as one of the top ten most influential publications ever published in the field of physics. The argument over EPR continues to this day. One common misconception is that quantum communications are faster than or close to the speed of light, which is not true. EPR proposes something similar. This contradiction is argued by EPR on the basis of locality and realism. Along with Quantum Entanglement, Einstein is dissatisfied Let me explain EPR’s reasoning before delving into the theory.

Locality refers to the fact that when two particles are separated by a distance, they cannot interact quickly. They need some time to pass on the information. In layman’s terms, “the physical process occurring at one place cannot have any influence in the other process at a location outside its light cone.”.

Realism: if we know the properties of a certain system and can forecast its progress, for example, if we know the mass and velocity of a specific object at a specific time, we can predict the distance travelled by that thing as time progresses. So, before the quantum arrived, all physical quantities were deterministic. Simply put, realism is that “a physical object and its properties pre-exist without the influence of an observer.”

Quantum Entanglement is illogical! Assume we have two distinct quantum particles named Alice and Bob. These two particles were quantum entangled and are separated by a large distance. This is now acting as a single, large system. When one tries to measure one of the particles, the other knows immediately that the measurement was conducted. This appears to be a violation of Einstein’s special theory of relativity, which states that nothing moves faster than light within the universe. Because of its superposition, quantum mechanical objects appear to lack locality and realism. When measured, the item remains in numerous states at the same time and is compressed into one of them. These factors combined cause Einstein to have strange feelings regarding quantum mechanics, which he labeled spukhafte Fernwirkungen (“spooky actions at a distance”).

EPR even argued that quantum theory is incomplete because there is something in the built-in system that we do not have access to. This could be due to a lack of knowledge, a lack of understanding, or simply the way the universe operates. And this strange thing tells the system how the result should be displayed when the measurement is performed on the system. This was later known as the hidden variable theory. If we know the hidden variable, quantum mechanics is complete and deterministic; the system will not collapse randomly.

During the twentieth century, there was a lot of scientific controversy around EPR. The entire physics community has been divided into advocates of EPR and critics of EPR (led by Neils Bohr). No one was able to argue against EPR for the next 30 years. John Stewart Bell, a physicist from Northern Ireland, offered a proposal to counter EPR in 1964. He proposed what is now known as Bell’s inequality. If it is violated by any system, the system is quantum in nature, which has had a significant impact and rapid development in quantum. Later in 1972, Freedman and Clauser experimentally violated Bell’s inequality and were also awarded the Noble Prize (2022) for Bell’s violation. I’ll write more about Bell inequality and CHSH violations in future blogs.

See Yaa,

Thirumalai Manimaran


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

One Brave Qubit Refusing DeCoherence

Hey there,  I'm wrapping up my year long exploration around quantum tech in 2025, yes this is my second of its kind next to "Kutty Story on Quantum -  Wrap of my Quantum Odyssey 2024". To be honest I was so active by last year, yet I started my career in Quantum in 2025, a transition phase from academic to industry. Ok whatever let's wrap it up, FYI you may not expect any scientific details in quantum, its all about personal journey in Quantum tech. I was in huge disappointment by dec 2024, so I did planned lot of things as expected I'm not able to execute many. I spend very less amount of time in my thesis compared 2024, and yes it has been submitted successfully. Graduated from IIT Jodhpur - Masters in Quantum Technology. Really so thankful to QIC department, IIT Jodhpur, especially inspiring Professors such as Prof Atul Kumar, Prof V Narayanan, Prof Kirankumar Hiremath and others. I really made lot friends and all my batchmates are in very good place now, I wis...

Kutty Story on Quantum - Wrap of my Quantum Odyssey 2024

 First of all if you have made to this page, thanks for making. Just a note the following will be a personal blog about my journey on Quantum tech in 2024. If at all you know me in person you might like the story and if you are someone who is working in Quantum Tech you might have some key takeaways. Again this going to be completely about Me and Quantum, so I’ll be bragging myself here and there. Ok Let’s dive… What you Seek is Seeking you ! I personally believe that Quantum is the one opted me and I’m just dancing through it, anyway I have to dance carefully hereafter. This year started with Bangg!! As a batch we have started Quantum Club at IIT Jodhpur and the whole batch elected me as Secretary, that moment I decided that it going to be a huge responsibility, since I was completely new to this field at that time and there are lot of Scholars in campus are already working extensively in Quantum tech for years. Anyways I knew that I can handle this, however most places I have str...

Once Upon a time in Physics: The Birth of Quantum Physics

  I was first introduced to the world of quantum mechanics through popular media like Marvel movies and online videos. As I advanced in my higher education, I found myself increasingly fascinated by the fundamental principles of quantum physics. What I realized is that the actual facts and phenomena, like quantum tunneling, quantum teleportation, quantum algorithms, quantum machine learning, quantum communication, etc., within the realm of quantum mechanics are often more astonishing and mind-boggling than the speculations and mysteries that occasionally surround them. One captivating example of this is the intriguing concept of quantum teleportation. The concept of quantum mechanics has generated a significant amount of excitement among people from various backgrounds. Quantum is no longer confined to the realms of science fiction or specialised scientific knowledge. This article aims to introduce the origins of quantum mechanics in simpler terms without delving too deeply into co...

Overview of Quantum Machine Learning (QML)

QML — It’s a complete new domain of research area which combines Principle of Quantum Computing and Machine Learning together. This is one of sub-group of Quantum computing. There will be series of blogs on QML starting from encoding mechanism to optimization. Not just limited to theory, there will be python code implementation as well. Qiskit will be the predominant library and here and there we will touch upon Pennylane and Cirq. So before continuing Quantum Computing, Machine learning and Deep Learning Algorithms, Qiskit, Pennylane will be considered as pre requisite. Image generated by napkin.ai One big question arises Why someone need QML ? There are some problems which cannot be solved classically, where quantum computing helps to achieve it with better performance. In some cases QML has given good results than classical machine learning. However QML is not as easy as ML, the difficulty starts with data encoding itself. One has to encode classical dataset into respective quantum ...

Superposition and Entanglement

  The two notable terms that attract people to quantum physics are superposition and entanglement. These two characteristics really have a significant impact on quantum computing. Superposition and entanglement will be utilized in quantum communications and information storage, respectively, in the future. Computers were typically controlled in bits, which are represented as 0 or 1. On the other hand, quantum computing makes use of quantum bits, or qubits, which exist in a condition known as the superposition state, which is a combination of 0 and 1. Let’s imagine that we can anticipate both a head and a tail result when a coin is thrown. However, a coin can exist in both the head and tail states in a quantum world. In physics, you may have studied the dual nature of light. We discovered that light behaves as both a wave and a particle in Young’s Double Slit Experiment with Interference Pattern. The method of experimentation determines the character of light. demonstrated how light...